Every week, the Business Seminar Series at the University of Dundee School of Business brings someone from practice into the room with our students. Two sessions this autumn stayed with me, partly because they came from such different careers and ended up making the same point.
Stuart Robertson: what employers actually expect
In October, Stuart Robertson, a business excellence leader and executive coach, spoke on working with industry: the expectations, pitfalls and opportunities graduates meet in their first roles. His message was practical. Nobody expects a graduate to know everything on day one, but they do need to move beyond doing only what they are asked. Reliability, communication and consistency are what build credibility.
He also gave students a simple plan for their first 90 days: listen and learn, then understand and contribute, then challenge and improve. The idea I keep coming back to with my own students is his advice to become known as someone who spots problems, takes ownership and helps to solve them.
Dr Ian Thomson: careers are not linear
In November, Dr Ian Thomson spoke about a career that has taken him from chartered accountancy to transformation director, leadership training in 45 countries and national president of Junior Chamber International. After decades at the top of industry he came back to Dundee for his doctorate, a DBA supervised by Professor Ian Robson, and turned his research into practical books for business leaders and entrepreneurs, including Above the Dry Cleaners and It’s Closer.
As Director of our MBA and DBA programmes, I was especially glad to see a DBA graduate show students what doctoral study grounded in practice can lead to. The lessons he shared were ones any student can use:
- You don’t need to see the whole journey, only enough light for the next step.
- Look for the doors, and be brave enough to open them.
- Careers aren’t linear, but there is always a thread that connects them.
- AI can be a useful writing partner, but your own stories and experience are what make the work worth reading.
From a seminar to a game
Ian’s book follows an adviser who helps clients by noticing what they don’t say and asking rather than telling. That approach became The Noticing Game, the newest game in my Learning Lab, made with Ian and inspired by Above the Dry Cleaners. Six fictional clients climb the stairs to an office above a dry cleaner’s with a question about tax, cash or growth. Players tap the sentences that matter, then choose the question that helps the client see their situation differently. It takes 10 to 20 minutes on your own, or 25 to 40 minutes as a class on one screen, and there is a teacher’s guide with every answer.
Both talks gave students the same message from different directions: you add value by paying attention and asking good questions, not by having every answer. Thank you to Stuart and Ian for giving their time, and to Kirsty Beaumont and Craig Reoch for bringing these real stories into the room every week.
Related reading on this site:
- Bringing industry into the classroom: a live client, a storyteller and a challenge to come
- The Dundee MBA and DBA
- Learning Lab: free teaching games and toolkits




